For the LOVE of a freakin' NY slice!!! Finally found THE closest at ElMar's!!! Thank you and God bless you! For those who don't know...NY pizza is set apart because of the WATER! What? Yes, NYC has some of the best water in the world...and is essential in making not only the ideal pizza crust, but the bagels too. ElMar's literally has a process that gets the water as close to replicating NYC water and its mineral content as possible. I'm from New York...trust me! Chef Kim does a decent job at Hello Pizza, but this pizza is far better imo. From New York with love

This place sells not only New York pizza but also New York bagels in the morning! The interior design is giving New York, so the entire experience is a fun experience! Wonderful place with great service! It's decently busy everyday but you get in and out fairly quick for the amount of people there! What to order: Pizza is fantastic!! Get this over a pasta in my opinion, however, the eggplant Parmesan (no pasta) is tasty! The bagels are large and puffed! I heard that this bagel shop brings in water from NY to make their bagels but I could be wrong! Regardless, the bagels were very flavorful with a large variety!

"You'll be back for more" said the guy behind the counter taking my order 9 minutes later, he was right I recommend the jalapeño honey sauce, if u like it a lil spicy

The bagels are to die for!!! I ordered online the night before and my order was ready for pickup at the expected time. I ordered a dozen bagels and a few containers of cream cheese and everybody in the office loved it. I highly recommend trying to stop in Thursday-Saturday AM to try some of their bagels! Very similar to the classic fluffy NYC style. If you're not sure what to try - the cinnamon sugar cream cheese is my favorite!

An absolute knock out pizza joint! Serving NY style pizza that is so light & crispy you won't believe it's in MN! We got the garbage, classic white & pepperoni. All three were delicious! They are in a strip mall so there is a decent sized parking lot. They staff was friendly the service was super fast. The inside is cozy but a little small so be prepared to wait for a table or take it to go. Next I'm going to try their bagels!

The pizza was amazing! Perfect bread. They are extremely generous with the toppings. Got a basic pepperoni to try out the place. It was amazing! This is our new go-to. Nice and warm, cheese wasn't overwhelming. Delicious sauce. Cinnamon knots were slightly overdone the icing that came with it was super runny like water. Wasn't terrible, but not great. Getting a 5 for the pizza since that's the star anyways!

Picked up the "garbage pizza" delicious NY style pizza with all the toppings A little on the spendy side but would order again if in the area

No need to fly to NY for Ny style pizza! Better than pizza shops in NY, including Bleeker Street and Joe's! The best part for me is the crust -- crunchy and chewy yeasty crust is perfect texture! While I love an all-meats topping, I think my favorite here is the classic Margherita. Simple. Beautiful. Classic. When too many toppings were involved, some of the individual flavors got lost. Delicious and affordable NY pizza Get a slice or get a whole 18" pie -- that'll be your hardest decision! My favorite is the Margherita -- simple classic done well! Second best imho is the chicken bacon ranch -- the dill adds SO MUCH to this and makes it so delicious! The Whoopty pie is also great -- simple with sausage, mushrooms, onions. No matter which pie you choose, they are all made with a deliciously chewy and crunchy crust! Just the way I love it! Was also informed that their dough also available for purchase. Be sure to order ahead to ensure you get what you want when you want it!!

I don't get out to Plymouth often so I've only been a couple of times. If I ever have to go out to a surrounding city...the pizza is so good, I'll make sure my errand will coincide w ElMar's open hours. It was easy and reasonably priced to get a couple slices to go. The slices wee still warm and delicious by the time I got home over a half hour later. I was happy w my choices of a Chicken Bacon Ranch slice and a cheese slice, named the Classic. The best part, this pizza isn't greasy like most places. Don't miss this delicious pizza, it's worth the drive.

I've heard so much praise for this place. I also heard that they ship their water from NYC to ensure it captures that true New York slice flavor. I was really looking forward to finally trying ElMar pizza but sadly for me it did not live up to the hype. First of all, everything I tried was lacking flavor! I thought the whoopty would have a kick to it, figured they used spicy sausage, but no, zero spice and zero salt. Also, I don't like that you can't order by the slice online/ahead of time. My family is all about plain cheese pizza but I love fun toppings, so I was excited that I could pick up a couple of unique slices for myself. However, I had to wait a good 15 min for my slices even though our pre-ordered pizza was ready to go. I understand that the logistics of letting people get different slices ahead of time are difficult but definitely a draw back for me. The crust really is good, I love how thin and crispy it is; definitely the star of the show! However, as I mentioned above, the blandness and the high price tag doesn't make me want to come back.