ElMar's New York Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

ElMar's New York Pizza in Plymouth, MN offers a taste of authentic New York pizza and bagels. Known for their unique process that replicates the quality of NYC water, their pizza crust is light and crispy, while their bagels are puffed and flavorful. Customers praise the generous toppings, delicious sauce, and perfect texture of the crust. The Margherita pizza is highly recommended for its simplicity and classic taste, along with the chicken bacon ranch pizza that offers a delightful twist with dill. While the prices may be slightly higher, the quality and taste make it worth the visit. Make sure to try their signature garbage pizza for a true New York style experience. With friendly service and fast turnaround times, ElMar's New York Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.